Trusted & Authentic Witchcraft Supplies: Moonlight Mysteries

Find Your Craft: The Online Witchcraft Store Built on Passion & Experience

In a search for spiritual supplies, what separates a simple spiritual shop or metaphysical store from a true partner in your practice? We believe it’s authenticity. It's the difference between mass-market novelties and a genuine ritual tool.

For over 20 years, Moonlight Mysteries has been that partner. We are a family-owned online witchcraft store founded on a deep passion for the craft, for all practitioners. We don't just sell Wiccan supplies; we curate tools born from a deep respect for pagan rituals—the ones that have power, history, and a spark of the divine.

Whether you're a seasoned practitioner or just gathering your first beginner witch kit, you'll find our collection is built for your path.

Build Your Sacred Space: Altar Tools & Ritual Supplies for All Practitioners

Your altar is the heart of your craft. We provide the complete, high-quality foundation for your sacred space.

• Core Altar Tools: Find practitioner-grade athames, chalices, heavy-iron cauldrons, for beautifully crafted altars.

• Energetic Essentials: Cleanse and consecrate with our pure herbs, oils, candles, incense, and energy-clearing sage wands.

• Divine Focus: Connect with your deities through a vast collection of altar statues and deity statues.

Awaken Your Intuition: Divination, Books & Crystals

A practice of witchcraft is a journey of knowledge. We stock the tools you need to see, learn, and grow.

• Divination Tools: Explore a curated collection of tarot cards and oracle decks. Discover the right pendulums and handmade crystal balls to connect with your inner wisdom.

• The Written Word: Chronicle your journey in our leather-bound Book of Shadows journals and grimoires. Expand your knowledge with our library of essential witchcraft books and spell books.

• Earth's Energy: Our collection of high-vibration crystals and gemstones is hand-selected for its energetic clarity and quality.

Wear Your Craft: Artisan Pagan Jewelry & Spells 

Your craft extends beyond your altar. We provide tools for focused work and wearable intention.

• Artisan & Pagan Jewelry: This is our passion. We are the proud, sole distributor for Paul Borda (Dryad Designs) and feature stunning handcrafted jewelry of Ted Andrews, Oberon Zell, and Master Craftsman Joseph "Pepi" Masselli.

• Spellwork: For focused intent, our exclusive Witchcraft Essentials line provides complete spell kits, herbal starter kits, witch herbs, ritual oils, candles and potent spell mixes, perfect for practitioners of all levels.

Our Pagan Roots: 20 Years of Community & Craft

We aren't just another online witchcraft store that popped up overnight.

Our story began in 2002, when founders Jason and Serenity first started sharing their passion for the craft at local Pagan Pride Day events near the beautiful Grand River in Grand Rapids, Michigan. From those simple beginnings, Moonlight Mysteries grew into a thriving and trusted Pagan store online, but they have never lost that small-town, community feel. 

Jason & Serenity are still working hard at Moonlight Mysteries, and are dedicated to supporting the witchcraft community and providing the tools that have empowered countless spiritual journeys over the last 20+ years.

Step into Our Circle

Are you tired of sorting through novelties of impersonal witchcraft stores? Find your home.

When you shop with Moonlight Mysteries, you’re getting more than just witchcraft supplies. You’re getting two decades of experience, award-winning customer service, fast & free shipping, and a partner who truly understands the needs of the craft.

Browse our full collection of genuine ritual tools and spiritual supplies that resonate with your practice and feel the difference authenticity makes.